Forum Home
Introduction
Terms of Use
RSS feed | RSS help
Introduction
Terms of Use
Posts by the blogger are highlighted in orange; posts by FQXi Members are highlighted in blue.
By using the FQXi Forum, you acknowledge reading and agree to abide by the Terms of Use RSS feed | RSS help
RECENT BLOG COMMENTS
Ray Munroe: "Dear Steve, You only have 5 strings on your guitar? Should I send an early..." in The Beautiful Truth
Steve Dufourny: "Hi Ray, It lacks a string on my guitar, Mi La Ré Sol Si Mi....it lacks the..." in The Beautiful Truth
Lawrence B. Crowell: "You can numerically integrate quantum problems. Doing this brings about..." in Quantum Dating Market
Jason Wolfe: "Georgina, Thanks for a good laugh! But you are right, freedom is better..." in Astrotheology: Do Aliens...
John Merryman: "Tom, My mistake. I was thinking you were considering Steve's seeming..." in Free Radical
Georgina Parry: "Jason, is that a rhetorical question? Would I accept a brain implant,..." in Astrotheology: Do Aliens...
Jason Wolfe: "Lawrence, I've been thinking about quantum mechanics with regards to the..." in Quantum Dating Market
Steve Dufourny: "I am going to share with you dear Tom , 50 per cent thus 1/2 million for..." in Free Radical
RECENT ARTICLES
click titles to read articles
Ripping Apart Einstein
Cutting the threads of the spacetime fabric and reinstating the "aether" could lead to a theory of quantum gravity.
Readers' Choice: Much Ado About Nothing
Does the vacuum regenerate itself to fill the gaps as spacetime is pulled apart? Could a growing vacuum explain dark energy?
Classic Article: Building a Better Black Hole
FQXi essay contest winner Louis Crane explains how artificial black holes might have controlled our universe’s past and could direct humanity’s future, in this classic article from 2007.
Editor's Choice: Taming Infinity
General relativity and quantum mechanics could be perfectly compatible—as long as you know how to handle infinity, that is.
Readers' Choice: True Lies: Why Mathematics is an Illusion
To find a theory of quantum gravity we may have to look through a different logical lens, abandoning conceptions of "truth" and "falsehood" and crossing over to a new "mathematical universe."
Ray Munroe: "Dear Steve, You only have 5 strings on your guitar? Should I send an early..." in The Beautiful Truth
Steve Dufourny: "Hi Ray, It lacks a string on my guitar, Mi La Ré Sol Si Mi....it lacks the..." in The Beautiful Truth
Lawrence B. Crowell: "You can numerically integrate quantum problems. Doing this brings about..." in Quantum Dating Market
Jason Wolfe: "Georgina, Thanks for a good laugh! But you are right, freedom is better..." in Astrotheology: Do Aliens...
John Merryman: "Tom, My mistake. I was thinking you were considering Steve's seeming..." in Free Radical
Georgina Parry: "Jason, is that a rhetorical question? Would I accept a brain implant,..." in Astrotheology: Do Aliens...
Jason Wolfe: "Lawrence, I've been thinking about quantum mechanics with regards to the..." in Quantum Dating Market
Steve Dufourny: "I am going to share with you dear Tom , 50 per cent thus 1/2 million for..." in Free Radical
RECENT ARTICLES
click titles to read articles
Ripping Apart Einstein
Cutting the threads of the spacetime fabric and reinstating the "aether" could lead to a theory of quantum gravity.
Readers' Choice: Much Ado About Nothing
Does the vacuum regenerate itself to fill the gaps as spacetime is pulled apart? Could a growing vacuum explain dark energy?
Classic Article: Building a Better Black Hole
FQXi essay contest winner Louis Crane explains how artificial black holes might have controlled our universe’s past and could direct humanity’s future, in this classic article from 2007.
Editor's Choice: Taming Infinity
General relativity and quantum mechanics could be perfectly compatible—as long as you know how to handle infinity, that is.
Readers' Choice: True Lies: Why Mathematics is an Illusion
To find a theory of quantum gravity we may have to look through a different logical lens, abandoning conceptions of "truth" and "falsehood" and crossing over to a new "mathematical universe."
FQXi BLOGS
March 12, 2010
Remember my radical idea from last August? This was the suggestion that microbial life might be lying dormant in the centers of some craters on the moon, having been transferred there, panspermia-style, via impactors originating elsewhere in the Solar System (or beyond). Perhaps Copernicus crater is right now home to a colony of alien bacteria, and the first samples of extraterrestrial...
view entire post
this post has been edited by the author since its original submission
post approved
Some scientists have proposed that complex molecules may have evolved inside comets and then delivered to Earth via glancing impacts or just via the comets shedding dust that than make it to Earth.
The very cold conditions inside comets make them ideal places to cook up complex molecules. In a test tube, the chemical reactions will produce the most stable compounds. You cannot make complex moleculs of which the intermedary products would be very unstable.
Inside a comet a molecule can react with another molecule in its immediate vicinity, without being bothered by oter molecules that are further away. This allows the formation of large molecules which will in general be very unstable at room temperatures. But some of these unstable molecules may then combine to form more stable molecules.
If the comet is kicked out of the Oort cloud and ends up in an elliptical orbit bringing it close to the Sun for short periods, then during the brief warm periods inside the comets, the unstable complex molecules will be destroyed, the more stable molecules may be able to survive. What may also happen is that different unstable molecules that are nstable on a time scale of a few hours may combine to form a molecule that is stable on a time scale of months. These more stable molecules will then be able to survive the brief warm period
Then, the comet moves away from the Sun, and reactions will be limited to close neighbors again. Cosmic rays may cause muations at greater disctances from the Sun. Molecules can then form unstable combinations with impunity again until the next warm period arrives.
post approved
The very cold conditions inside comets make them ideal places to cook up complex molecules. In a test tube, the chemical reactions will produce the most stable compounds. You cannot make complex moleculs of which the intermedary products would be very unstable.
Inside a comet a molecule can react with another molecule in its immediate vicinity, without being bothered by oter molecules that are further away. This allows the formation of large molecules which will in general be very unstable at room temperatures. But some of these unstable molecules may then combine to form more stable molecules.
If the comet is kicked out of the Oort cloud and ends up in an elliptical orbit bringing it close to the Sun for short periods, then during the brief warm periods inside the comets, the unstable complex molecules will be destroyed, the more stable molecules may be able to survive. What may also happen is that different unstable molecules that are nstable on a time scale of a few hours may combine to form a molecule that is stable on a time scale of months. These more stable molecules will then be able to survive the brief warm period
Then, the comet moves away from the Sun, and reactions will be limited to close neighbors again. Cosmic rays may cause muations at greater disctances from the Sun. Molecules can then form unstable combinations with impunity again until the next warm period arrives.
post approved
Count –
By your command.
I had a conversation with Max Wallis at the Cardiff Centre for Astrobiology in Wales a few years back during which he made a compelling case for exactly this possibility. Asteroids, as he said, “are pretty dead,” whereas
“I think comets can form an environment in their interior in which elementary life can replicate, survive and travel in a sheltered environment to another stellar system.”
That’s a quotation that appears in the article I was writing at the time, “What If Life On Earth Did Not Begin On Earth?” which is now online at Red Ice, if you are interested.
This Discover article is also fun. “Intersetellar clouds of gas are impregnated with organic molecules . . .”
William
post approved
By your command.
I had a conversation with Max Wallis at the Cardiff Centre for Astrobiology in Wales a few years back during which he made a compelling case for exactly this possibility. Asteroids, as he said, “are pretty dead,” whereas
“I think comets can form an environment in their interior in which elementary life can replicate, survive and travel in a sheltered environment to another stellar system.”
That’s a quotation that appears in the article I was writing at the time, “What If Life On Earth Did Not Begin On Earth?” which is now online at Red Ice, if you are interested.
This Discover article is also fun. “Intersetellar clouds of gas are impregnated with organic molecules . . .”
William
post approved
Add a New Post